Insights

A fractured vote and a closing trade door

Steyn Mc Dowall · 9 November 2026

Voters have handed most of the big cities to coalitions that do not yet exist, in the same week that Washington confirmed the end of duty-free access. The next five years of municipal delivery will be negotiated, not won.

A fractured vote and a closing trade door

Each risk is classified by severity, reach and onset, with its direction of travel and risk transfer position.

The view ahead

Voters have handed most of the big cities to coalitions that do not yet exist, in the same week that Washington confirmed the end of duty-free access. The next five years of municipal delivery will be negotiated, not won.

The 4 November local government election has redrawn the map of urban power. With about two-thirds of voting districts counted, the ANC held 31.7 percent of the national vote and the DA 25.1 percent, and later counts reported in the press show the gap holding. The DA leads in Johannesburg, Tshwane, Ekurhuleni, Cape Town and Nelson Mandela Bay, the MK Party leads eThekwini with 44.4 percent, and more than 100 municipalities could need coalitions. Results remain provisional while the electoral commission works through more than 800 complaints and recount requests in KwaZulu-Natal. Both main parties have pulled coalition talks under national control to avoid unstable local deals. The incoming councils inherit severe water losses, high unemployment and, in Johannesburg, a R10.3 billion wage agreement signed hours before the vote.

We expect coalition formation to dominate the rest of November and the first quarter of 2027, and we expect the quality of those agreements to decide whether services improve or decay further. Johannesburg, Tshwane and eThekwini carry the most risk, because their water systems are failing and their finances are weakest. The confirmed loss of Agoa from 1 January 2027 will cost less than feared overall, since only about 1 percent of exports used it, but it lands on vehicles, citrus and wine, and it arrives as consumers report the tightest finances in a year. Fuel relief has been almost wholly absorbed by higher oil prices and a weaker rand, electricity output is falling, and public clinics face record medicine shortages. Clients with operations in the metros, exports to the United States or staff reliant on public health care will feel these pressures first.

Risks at a glance

Severity is how hard the risk lands. Reach is how far it travels: contained to one sector, connected across several, or systemic across the economy. Onset is how soon it arrives: immediate, building over coming months, or long-range. Nothing this week is rated severe.

RiskSeverityReachOnsetDirection
POL-01Hung metros and coalition governmentMajorConnectedImmediate Rising
HLT-01Record public-sector medicine shortagesMajorConnectedImmediate Rising
MAC-01Fuel relief absorbed by oil and the randMajorSystemicImmediate Rising
POL-05eThekwini and KwaZulu-Natal after the voteModerateConnectedImmediate Rising
ECO-05Household financial strainModerateSystemicImmediate Rising
ENE-03Falling electricity output and costModerateSystemicBuilding Rising
INF-04Gauteng water supply failureModerateConnectedImmediate Rising
GEO-01Loss of Agoa from January 2027ModerateConnectedBuilding Stable
GOV-02Procurement challenges and asset recoveryModerateConnectedBuilding Stable
GOV-14Johannesburg wage deal and city financesModerateContainedBuilding Stable
CLI-04Climate policy and the mining transitionMinorConnectedLong-range Stable
REG-05Walvis Bay as a regional fuel hubMinorConnectedLong-range Stable

Dates that will move the picture

Mid-Nov
Electoral commission declares results after objectionsPOL-01
9 to 20 Nov
COP31 climate conference in AntalyaCLI-04
Late Nov
First council sittings elect mayors and speakersPOL-01
1 Dec
Full fuel levy relief ends, smaller cuts continueMAC-01
1 Jan 2027
South Africa's Agoa eligibility endsGEO-01
5 Jan 2027
Remaining fuel levy relief endsMAC-01
2027
Minister reconsiders lottery licence under suspended orderGOV-02
Apr 2028
China's two-year zero-tariff window for African goods closesGEO-01
Mid-2028
Walvis Bay fuel storage and pipeline due for completionREG-05

Opportunities worth watching

Zero tariffs in China. Exports to China rose 24 percent between May and August after Beijing removed tariffs on qualifying African goods, with agricultural exports up more than 35 percent.

A reset with Washington. The President expects a Democratic Congress to help repair relations and has called for talks on a bilateral trade agreement to replace Agoa.

Smelters back on line. Two ferrochrome smelters are restarting after new Eskom pricing agreements, showing that negotiated tariffs can bring energy-intensive processing back.

Natural diamond demand. Botswana reports rising demand for natural diamonds in the United States and India, which supports regional mining suppliers and payment flows.

Risk register

Each card carries the risk, its category, severity, reach, onset, direction of travel and risk transfer position, together with the response we recommend.

Insurable
Three blocks. Cover readily placed in the local market.
Partially insurable
Two blocks. Cover available for part of the exposure, locally or internationally, with material exclusions.
Not insurable
One block. No insurance market responds. The exposure is managed, hedged or retained.

Major severity

POL-01

Hung metros and coalition government

Category
Political
Severity
Major
Reach
Connected
Onset
Immediate
Direction
Rising
Insurance
Partially insurable

With two-thirds of districts counted, the ANC had 31.7 percent and the DA 25.1 percent, and more than 100 municipalities could need coalitions. The DA leads five metros and the MK Party eThekwini. Both main parties have centralised coalition talks to avoid unstable deals. Results are provisional until objections are resolved, and most large metros will need agreements to govern.

What we recommend

Map which councils govern your key sites and plan for slower decisions while coalitions form. Build service and permit delays into first-quarter 2027 plans.

HLT-01

Record public-sector medicine shortages

Category
Health
Severity
Major
Reach
Connected
Onset
Immediate
Direction
Rising
Insurance
Partially insurable

More than one in seven medicines on the Health Department's master list are at risk of running out, with critical shortages of 165 products, including cancer and psychiatric drugs. Patients are buying treatment privately. Causes include global supply disruption, unpaid state bills, local manufacturers missing regulatory standards and weaknesses in the tender system, so recovery will be slow.

What we recommend

Employers should check how staff on chronic treatment through public clinics are affected and support access where needed. Healthcare suppliers should review stock and payment exposure to the state.

MAC-01

Fuel relief absorbed by oil and the rand

Category
Macro and energy
Severity
Major
Reach
Systemic
Onset
Immediate
Direction
Rising
Insurance
Not insurable

Petrol fell by only one cent a litre in November despite the R1.50 levy cut, while diesel fell by R1.10 to R1.20. Brent crude rose from $101 to $108 a barrel over the review period on Middle East tensions, and the rand weakened, offsetting most of the R10 billion relief. Full relief ends on 1 December and the rest on 5 January, so prices could rise sharply in January.

What we recommend

Keep hedges and fuel escalation clauses in place and do not budget on the levy cut. Model margins for a January price rise when relief ends.

Moderate severity

POL-05

eThekwini and KwaZulu-Natal after the vote

Category
Political
Severity
Moderate
Reach
Connected
Onset
Immediate
Direction
Rising
Insurance
Partially insurable

The MK Party leads eThekwini with 44.4 percent, short of a majority, so the metro that hosts the country's main port faces coalition talks. The electoral commission is investigating recount calls in parts of KwaZulu-Natal, where counting restarted at some stations. eThekwini loses more than half its water, and murder remains high in Durban. Disputes over the count are untested.

What we recommend

Prepare for a period of uncertain governance in eThekwini and review port, logistics and water continuity plans for Durban. Confirm riot cover and the Sasria excess.

ECO-05

Household financial strain

Category
Economy
Severity
Moderate
Reach
Systemic
Onset
Immediate
Direction
Rising
Insurance
Not insurable

NielsenIQ finds 41 percent of consumers feel worse off than a year ago, up from 37 percent, while only 38 percent feel better off. Food prices top the list of concerns, followed by utilities and transport. More than four in ten have stopped buying some products, many are switching to discount retailers, and one in four may borrow more, which raises credit risk heading into the festive season.

What we recommend

Consumer-facing clients should plan for trading down through the festive season. Lenders and retailers should tighten credit criteria and collections.

ENE-03

Falling electricity output and cost

Category
Energy
Severity
Moderate
Reach
Systemic
Onset
Building
Direction
Rising
Insurance
Not insurable

Electricity production fell 5.2 percent in September from a year earlier while consumption rose 1.5 percent, and output for the first nine months was 6.9 percent lower. Imports rose 78.4 percent. Government plans 102GW of new capacity, 60 percent renewable, but that is a long-range answer. A widening gap between supply and demand raises the risk of renewed load reduction and higher prices.

What we recommend

Test continuity plans against a return of supply interruptions. Pursue own generation, storage and negotiated tariffs before peak summer demand.

INF-04

Gauteng water supply failure

Category
Infrastructure
Severity
Moderate
Reach
Connected
Onset
Immediate
Direction
Rising
Insurance
Partially insurable

Johannesburg's reservoirs cannot recover under high demand, causing low pressure and outages from Sandton and Midrand to Soweto, and the city is throttling supply. The Human Rights Commission says Gauteng's outages stem from failed maintenance, not shortage, and warns that tanker contracts invite corruption. Tshwane spent R326 million on tankers in 2025/26 while losing water worth R1.7 billion a year.

What we recommend

Install or confirm on-site storage at Gauteng sites and agree contingency supply. Record outage durations to support any claim or rates dispute.

GEO-01

Loss of Agoa from January 2027

Category
Geopolitical
Severity
Moderate
Reach
Connected
Onset
Building
Direction
Stable
Insurance
Not insurable

Washington will end South Africa's Agoa eligibility from 1 January 2027, citing trade barriers, corruption and foreign policy. Agoa exports fell to about R28 billion in 2025, roughly 1 percent of all exports, so economists expect a limited national effect. The cost falls on vehicles, citrus and wine; vehicle exports to the US had already dropped 83 percent under 25 percent tariffs.

What we recommend

Reprice 2027 United States contracts at full tariffs and add adjustment clauses now. Use the Chinese zero-tariff window and other markets to diversify before January.

GOV-02

Procurement challenges and asset recovery

Category
Governance
Severity
Moderate
Reach
Connected
Onset
Building
Direction
Stable
Insurance
Partially insurable

The High Court has set aside the National Lottery licence because a ministerial committee reassessed bids outside the tender process, though it made no adverse finding against the winner and suspended the order to protect operations. Separately, a court ordered former Bosasa executive Angelo Agrizzi to pay the state R1.67 billion; he intends to appeal. Both show courts reopening state awards.

What we recommend

Treat any state award as open to review until the process is shown to be clean, and keep full bid records. Price challenge risk into public-sector contracts.

GOV-14

Johannesburg wage deal and city finances

Category
Governance
Severity
Moderate
Reach
Contained
Onset
Building
Direction
Stable
Insurance
Not insurable

Johannesburg signed a R10.3 billion wage agreement with Samwu hours before the vote, despite the Finance Minister forbidding it and a failed DA court bid. R1.2 billion has already been paid to about 37 000 workers. The deal binds the incoming administration, whoever governs, and may crowd out maintenance and infrastructure spending in a city already short of funds.

What we recommend

Suppliers to Johannesburg should tighten payment terms and watch for delays. Expect pressure on rates and tariffs as the city seeks revenue.

Minor severity

CLI-04

Climate policy and the mining transition

Category
Climate
Severity
Minor
Reach
Connected
Onset
Long-range
Direction
Stable
Insurance
Not insurable

The Minerals Council wants climate policy to encourage mining investment and to let companies set their own route to net zero, balancing decarbonisation with energy security and competitiveness. It published its position ahead of COP31 in Antalya from 9 to 20 November. The outcome will shape carbon pricing and disclosure expectations for mining and its suppliers over years, not months.

What we recommend

Mining and heavy industrial clients should keep transition plans and emissions data current. Track COP31 outcomes for changes in disclosure and financing terms.

REG-05

Walvis Bay as a regional fuel hub

Category
Regional
Severity
Minor
Reach
Connected
Onset
Long-range
Direction
Stable
Insurance
Not insurable

The Dangote group has launched a $2.5 billion fuel storage and pipeline project at Walvis Bay, with about 600 million litres of storage, eight times Namibia's current national capacity. Due within 18 to 20 months, it aims to supply six countries. The project could redirect regional fuel flows away from South African ports and suppliers, though delivery on that timetable is not assured.

What we recommend

Fuel distributors and logistics firms serving neighbouring states should assess how a Walvis Bay hub would affect their routes and pricing. Explore supply or partnership options.

Where insurance carries the load

This week's register leans towards the balance sheet: no risk is rated fully insurable, five sit in the middle and seven fall outside any market. Sasria remains the sole route for riot and public disorder losses, and the disputed counts in KwaZulu-Natal and coalition deadlock in the metros are the triggers to watch. Infectious-disease and supply-chain extensions do not answer medicine shortages; group health cover and medical schemes meet treatment costs only where medicines can be found. A utilities extension answers a physical failure of supply, but throttling, low pressure and intermittent supply in Johannesburg and Tshwane may fall below the threshold or outside the wording. Directors and officers, legal expenses and fidelity cover answer defence costs and employee dishonesty where clients are drawn into procurement disputes, while confiscation orders and fines remain uninsurable, because cover for a penalty offends public policy.

For Agoa, exporters should reprice United States contracts at full most-favoured-nation tariffs from 1 January, build adjustment clauses into supply agreements and use the two-year Chinese zero-tariff window to open alternative markets. For fuel, the lesson of November is that a levy cut does not guarantee a lower price, so hedges and escalation clauses should stay in place through the 5 January expiry. Falling electricity output calls for own generation, storage and negotiated tariffs of the kind that brought the ferrochrome smelters back. Household strain and the Johannesburg wage settlement call for tighter credit terms with consumer-facing customers and the city, and for pricing that assumes trading down continues. Climate policy and the Walvis Bay fuel hub are slower exposures, best handled in strategy and supply contracts rather than in cover. Where an exposure is retained deliberately, consider alternative risk transfer mechanisms to ring-fence a funded reserve, though fines stay outside it and the structure should be tested with a broker first.

Severity: severe, major, moderate, minor, limited. Reach: contained, connected, systemic. Onset: immediate, building, long-range. Ratings are analyst judgements. Matters before the courts are allegations until determined. This brief is general information and not advice on any specific decision.

Share this article